Tuesday, February 24, 2015

Betrayed Expectations

Frankly, it sucks to be Esther.

If you disagree, think about it: she constantly blames herself for her listlessness, she feels misplaced and removed from reality, and she lacks several qualities that society expects her to have. Not to mention that she's in a situation that many other women would kill to be in. But it seems that her "ideal" life is far from picturesque.

The first two chapters do a fine job of displaying the contrast between fantasy and reality. Esther, a talented girl finds herself in an envious position. She's in New York, one can only imagine all of the adventures that she could be experiencing. But maybe there's something that these coming of age protagonists realize that we don't; after all, Holden Caulfield was in New York and he too thought of The City That Never Sleeps as rather soulsucking and dreary.

Romance is quashed almost immediately as well. New York, the Big Apple, kissing your beloved as the new year turns. What a romantic city. But Esther's peak at Doreen's encounter with Lenny proves to be both disturbing and disgusting; Lenny calls Doreen a "bitch" when she bites him and her breasts fall out of the dress as they continue to do their grotesque intertwining of their bodies. The evening ends with Doreen, a girl that Esther idolized for her beautiful appearance and boundless confidence, becoming a heap in a pool of vomit outside of Esther's door.

Even worse, the romantic "mood" -- if one can call it that -- continues throughout chapters five and six. I honestly don't see Buddy as the ideal man that Esther can marry; sure, he's nice, but there's definitely a misogynistic undertone that would inevitably stifle Esther's aspirations should they get married.

I mean, stripped to the bare bones -- and we will get to the stripping scene, just later -- Buddy looks great. He's from Yale, he's handsome, athletic, religious, loves his parents, will ultimately become rich and successful. The laundry list of his good qualities could go on and on. But then he cheats on Esther unapologetically. He expects that all of her ambitions, career wise, will disappear as soon as she gives birth and becomes a mother. He asks Esther if she'd like to see him naked, and upon her affirmation, takes off his clothes in a weirdly professional way.

We're no strangers to societal expectations and it's refreshing to see a novel discuss them so openly as well as provide us with a plethora of details to wrinkle our noses at. But these traditions seem to do only one thing: hurt. Esther represses herself, feeling as though she can't reveal her "true" self because that would make her undesirable. At this point, I can feel Esther grappling with touchy subjects; why is she the only odd one out? Everyone else is enjoying their time, what's wrong with her? Why her and not them? I hesitate to jump to the darkest conclusion, but if this problem persists and Esther isn't going to get the mental health treatment that she needs, she may just attempt a permanent solution to a temporary problem.

4 comments:

  1. Yeah, I really feel like Esther is just being strangled by her society, and while it does seem like there was a point when Esther was fighting back, now she is unfortunately starting to see that death might be her only way out. Its so incredibly depressing that it makes the novel difficult to read, not because of the density of the single page but the black storm cloud of depression that lingers over each chapter. So you're right: it sucks to be Esther, and it makes me wish Holden could read Bell Jar to see how good he has it (as a man).

    ReplyDelete
  2. I completely agree. I've really enjoyed reading this book--at first when I was reading it, I was comparing it to The Catcher in the Rye and I kind of thought it was less dark, but as I continued it to read it, and as far as we are in it now, it continues to get increasingly dark. I really like Esther as a character, she seems nice and sweet, but it is hard for me to read about her sometimes, especially in the most recent chapters we've read where she thinks about how to kill herself. Also, Esther and romance just don't seem to make sense with me--I could never see her getting married, but that may be because every man she's been with doesn't seem to quite understand her.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Your observation that Esther tends to blame herself for her struggles to engage is important. Whereas with Holden there was some underlying subtext of self-blame, for the most part he couches his struggles as a matter of the world "depressing" him, failing to live up to his expectations. Esther looks at everyone else seeming to get along just fine, and she figures she must have done something wrong, not achieved quite enough, or maybe something is just inherently off about her.

    Needless to say, as much as both situations are difficult, Holden's is a more empowering position--he at least feels confident "talking back" critically at the world, articulating relentlessly his dissatisfaction. One measure of Esther's development back to mental health, in my

    ReplyDelete
  4. Ahh! Didn't mean to hit "publish." Don't even think I *did* hit "publish." But no arguing with machines.

    Anyway, to complete a sentence: One measure of Esther's development back to mental health, in my reading, is that she comes to more comfortably occupy this critical-outsider role, to see that there are problems with the sexual double standard and she's not crazy for thinking so, and also to see that the social world is somewhat more navigable than she had previously believed. And as we discussed in class, Dr. Nolan is pivotal in this development, for a range of reasons, but most starkly with her one empowering declaration of the Reader's Digest article (which Esther had taken as gospel) to be "Propaganda!"

    ReplyDelete