In a race to find the world's next angsty protagonist, we've scoured the globe for teens who had deep apprehension to their future. And now, we've reached the finale, where one young adult will walk away with it all!
If Coming of Age was a reality tv show instead of an English class, this would basically be the opening to the ending. The beginning of the end. The "I don't have another analogy but go along with it for the sake of the rules of threes".
Since the only two protagonists that we've experienced as a class are Stephen and Holden, they'd be in the finale. Do they deserve to be there? Eh. Debatable. But if there were a certain stereotype that a coming of age youth should have, Stephen and Holden have many striking similarities that end up becoming telling traits.
Holden and Stephen are restless creatures; they move from place to place, Holden from prep school to prep school and Stephen from obscure location to obscure location. While it may seem that Holden is more in control of where he goes, Stephen would be bouncing around prep school to prep school too if it weren't for his family's declining wealth. Additionally, no matter what location the teenagers find themselves in, they tend to wander around, looking for something to do or just needing a place to think.
But what's truly important is how the childhood naiveté that follows Stephen around in chapter 1 is something that we never get to see with Holden, mainly because he doesn't want to let us see it. But obviously he cherishes that time; nostalgia creeps in and it's clear that he wants to return to a time where things were simple, if the entirety of the novel and Holden's catcher in the rye dream is any indication. But this naiveté is replaced by moral cynicism when something devastating happens. Holden's moment where he gets the essential "blue screen of death", human edition, is when Allie dies. Stephen's moment is harder to pinpoint; I want to say that his moment is when his dad makes fun of him telling on Father Dolan to the rector. But it's also likely that it was a combination of the aforementioned moment and his family's declining wealth that finally made Stephen view the world through a more negative light.
As their innocence leaves, they both realize that change is never positive. The reason why they're trying to resist the inevitable change that's coming up; nothing good can come out of it. One could argue that Stephen and Holden come off as identical solely because they are both lost teenagers coming of age and trying to find their place in the world. While this may sound plausible, not every coming of age teen is a bundle of angst wandering the universe in a search of their purpose.
So in a reality tv show finale between Stephen Dadelus and Holden Caulfield, who would win?
This is a really interesting post. While reading about Holden, once in a while I stop and think about how he is remarkably similar to Stephen--in a sense that he feels quite alienated and alone in his thoughts. But, other times, I am stricken by how different he is--Holden is talkative and rambunctious, while Stephen largely kept to himself. Both of those observations are large generalizations, but they are things I have noticed. Your post is interesting because I find it quite true, Holden manages to only tell us a portion of his life while we get to see the progression of Stephen's. I
ReplyDeleteI think that you ask an interesting question at the end. I can't see that Stephen Dedalus would be interested at all in a reality TV show, and Holden would likely be upset to be included. A key difference I see between the two of them is that while both want to be independent and not "phony," they have varying amounts of success because of personality differences. Holden is very anti-"phony" but doesn't have anything particular which he is actually going towards, so he gets condemned to wander around in futile lowliness. Stephen knows he wants to be an artist, and rejects phoniness as part of this quest. If Stephen is true to himself by rejecting what other people tell him specifically because it limits his chosen pursuits, Holden seems to lack these types of goals which underly his rejection.
ReplyDeleteI'd give the prize to Holden. His life has been much more terrible than Stephen's; whereas Holden's pain is caused by the death and trauma of his experiences, Stephen's is rooted in his sense of superiority.
ReplyDeleteI think you bring up an interesting point about how "the childhood naiveté that follows Stephen around in chapter 1 is something that we never get to see with Holden." While I agree with your point--we don't explicitly see Holden as a kid--I got the sense that Holden was never really able to move past the naive child stage. He acts very childlike when threatened with injustice and the adult world, and I think that's his way of distancing himself from the phonies (or maybe he just can't help it). I guess what I'm trying to say is even though we don't see kid Holden, I feel that he hasn't quite shed the naivete that's coupled with childhood.