Saturday, April 4, 2015

Burn That Bridge

Ruthie's emotional unavailability is something to be examined; without it, I don't see her and Lucille reaching that low point in Chapter 7.

We can already tell that she lacks empathy to certain tragedies; how many times has "a weasel sliding off a rock" been brought up in class? On one hand, the fact that she's not a "talk-about-your-feelings-wear-heart-on-sleeve" kind of gal is good; she can keep her cool when dealing with issues. But on the other hand, she risks being misunderstood and accused of not caring. Even Lucille, when mad at her, yells this: "All you ever do is just stand around like some stupid zombie! (127)".

Every time we see Ruthie show emotion, well, it's either to us, the readers -- the story is told from her perspective for a reason -- or when she's by herself in the wilderness. To put it simply, it's all too easy for a younger sister yearning for a caring, expressive, mother figure to assume that Ruthie's not affected or bothered by anything. To some extent, that's true. Ruthie isn't bothered because she's like Sylvie, but the ending of the novel really shows us that she does care and think about Lucille a lot.

Think about it from Lucille's perspective: she's all alone. Sylvie and Ruthie are perceived to be dead and it's most likely that Lucille has a lot of regrets as to what she could have said.

Originally, I used the word "criticized" instead of "examined" in the first sentence, which is a significantly less harsh word. Abandoning is a harsh word as well; there's such a focus on pointing the finger, assigning the blame, that I can't help but raise an eyebrow. It's easy to spin it that Lucille abandoned the loner Ruthie for the popular crowd, but it's also easy to spin it so that Lucille was trying to help Ruthie in the only way she knew how and Ruthie just walked away from her.

There may also be merit in examining how loose their moral compass was, but Ruthie and Lucille are just two characters written as sisters where this type of falling-out, in this situation, was inevitable. It's not like they were raised under the a roof where it was encouraged to say "what you did hurt my feelings"; Helen wasn't exactly a stellar parent. Tangentially, they might have wanted to say that after Helen's death, but the only person who could apologize for that would have been Helen, who was dead.

Bringing it back, Lucille is the sort of girl who's blunt and says what she's thinking. This is seen in when she first questions Sylvie and generally throughout the book. Lucille could have been a girl who desired to be part of the cool kids but kept it to herself, but she wasn't.

Some people see being alone as meaning "no one is around you", but I believe that it means "you are not connected to anyone". Lucille was alone in that house. Sure, she had Ruthie and Sylvie, but it's not like she felt connected to Sylvie in the first place. Additionally, she started feeling like she couldn't understand Ruthie anymore; the connection, the bond that they had, was slowly fading away.

Ruthie and Lucille would have reached a breaking point anyways because of the inevitable clash of their personalities, but I feel that if they had one "heart-to-heart" conversation and were a lot more open with each other, the parting would have been less crippling.

1 comment:

  1. I think the idea of being alone is really important to the Lucille dynamics. Transience suggests moving from place to place, and while Ruth and Sylvie end up literally doing that, they have each other as a perpetual constant. Ruth goes from Lucille to Sylvie quite quickly, never really being alone at all but Lucille, once done with Ruth is in a way forced to be transient, never finding someone to be tethered to.

    ReplyDelete