At first, I couldn't understand the hype of David Mitchell. Cloud Atlas? Whatever. The librarian named "Ian" gushing to me about how good Mitchell was at weaving together characters into one huge universe and how his newest book had cameos from all the protagonists while I was attempting to borrow Black Swan Green from the Urbana Free Library? I tried to Holden Caulfield-esque lie my way through the entire conversation.
(Then again, I've only recently gotten into tackling the "Want to Read" books on my GoodReads account, but still. Wasn't a Mitchell fan coming into this novel.)
But I have to give credit to how masterful Goose Fair set up for Disco to happen, and how masterful Disco seems to wrap everything up. In fact, everything was tied together so neatly and nicely that it felt like an ending, with January Man as a conclusive epilogue. We see Jason mature from a self-conscious, desperate-to-blend-in adolescent into a relatively smooth guy who manages to get not one, not two, but three kisses from Holly. His mother and father finally split -- we don't get to see much of them in those two chapters, aside from Jason's dad at the fair -- and his relationship with Julia is no longer as rocky as the pejorative "Thing" that she had been so fond of using.
Mitchell creates a world in which Jason must come to terms with his own identity. In Black Swan Green, Jason is give the perfect environment to defeat Hangman once and for all. Instead of giving into the turbulence from his parents's rocky relationship along with his own fears of fitting in at school, Jason is able to gain immense mental strength. This, in turn, allows for Jason to define himself instead of letting everyone else define him.
Page 291 sums up this new and reborn Jason pretty well:
The world's a headmaster who works on your faults. I don't mean in a mystical or a Jesus way. More how you'll keep tripping over a hidden step, over and over, till you finally understand: Watch out for that step!
Jason is able to defeat the Hangman because it's a mental issue. He's able to "watch out for that step!" in light of who he is and who he wishes to become. He's really come a long way from the pipsqueak I imagined in the first January Man, from the boy who was preoccupied with the Hangman's Four Commandments.
Yeah, from reading BSG, Mitchell comes across as a really talented author. Keep in mind he's an adult writing this, and he does an extremely good job of writing the novel through the eyes of a young boy. As a young boy (a bit older than Jason, but still) it feels very natural to read this book. While I may not relate to everything that Jason is feeling, I can understand what's going through his head.
ReplyDelete"At first, I couldn't understand the hype of David Mitchell. Cloud Atlas? Whatever." Fight me.
ReplyDeleteJokes aside, though, I agree that "Disco" was a satisfying end to Black Swan Green. I'll miss Jason's shenanigans and all the insightful/poetic observations he makes about the world. There are pockets of Black Swan Green that feel slightly fantastic and out of this world--Mme Crommelnyck, the house in the woods, Spooks, the Gypsies--but I think it goes to show that the ordinary can be magical if we see it in the right light. Although I don't share much in common with Jason on the surface, it feels like he plucks thoughts from out my head and puts them on the page. As a result, when Jason overcomes his Hangman and grows, I feel like some part of me has, too.