I'd like to say that I'm pretty attuned to patterns. When something happens once, twice, thrice, and then for a fourth time, one can be fairly sure that it'll happen again. So, looking towards the future, I am already anticipating the question: "Does Jason come of age at the end of the novel?"
Naturally, it's hard to say for sure whether or not he "comes of age" because we don't know what the ending is like. In fact, as a class, we're only on the third installment of his thirteen-month life. And, of course, there's always the readily available "but what do you mean by coming of age?" question so we never truly answer "yes" or "no", but rather "given this definition: yes, given this definition: no".
(I do this quite a lot.)
Personally, I struggle with accepting that Jason "coming of age", in the whole "mature adult" sense as a 13 year old. The thought makes me very uncomfortable; as I have stated before in a comment on CR's blog, Jason still has four years of high school to make it through. Bildungsroman not, my youthful protagonist, enjoy your days when you thought eighth grade was hard!
As a middle schooler, I can't remember being too preoccupied with fitting in. Then again, I often dressed in vibrant, almost gaudy clothes that poorly fit my body, so I suppose that fitting in shouldn't have been my biggest concern (if that were the case!) for I was in desperate need of a fashion sense. Realistically, however, my biggest concern at the time was probably whether or not I'd be able to drink all of the weird milk flavors at 7-11. Did I bildungsroman through life when I was in eighth grade? No! Did I bildungsroman through life my senior year? Debatable at this point, really.
Intellectually, one can say that Jason is light years ahead of his peers. His vocabulary is rich, his mind is able to think up of possible pitfalls and synonyms on the spot, and he has a way with words given his illustrious career as a poet. So why does it bother me that he can potentially be light years ahead of his peers in terms of maturity? Is it because of the way that I view maturing as moving on from childhood innocence? Is it because I want Jason to stay the 8th grader he is? Is it because I feel like it'll be harder to relate to a 13 year old who's got the world already figured out?
Who knows. But I guess that I'll be reading the book with mild trepidation.
I agree. I think that Jason won't come to a complete the coming of age process, because I still haven't and I'm four years older than he is! I hope that by the end of the novel he comes at least to a point in his life where he's more confident about himself and is ready to take on life a little bit less fearful of what others might think of him.
ReplyDeleteI don't know, I kind of like the idea of seeing a much younger person work through the coming-of-age thing. Maybe it's just because I'm not too worried about him "finishing" it. Especially at his age it feels like there's no worry that Mitchell is just gonna sign off with Jason as a fully-fleshed adult-in-a-kid's-body, or with some kind of holy revelation. I think this book will be more like Catcher than Portrait, in that Jason will end it not having figured out what he wants to do with the rest of his life, but just with a little more perspective on the limitations of his life and personality. That's one of the things I liked best about Catcher: Holden doesn't really "grow up," he just changes in small ways that help him (hopefully) find more peace with the world around him. That doesn't seem like a bad thing to hope for with Jason.
ReplyDeleteIt might be good to keep in mind many of the ideas that came out in our early discussion about the nature of coming-of-age (which were followed through on many of the blogs in the first weeks of class), wherein it's understood as an ongoing process that doesn't necessarily have a clearly defined point of achievement. It's true that Jason's youth means it would be hard to imagine the process being "complete" by the close of the novel--but then, is the process complete for Stephen, Holden, or Esther? (Ruth is a different story, perhaps.) We keep seeing these characters left off somewhere different from where they began, with some significant growth evident, and we might feel optimistic about where they're headed--but we're still aware that we're talking about *potential* rather than *achieved* maturity.
ReplyDeleteAnd in this novel, like so many others, the adults themselves don't always (ever?) behave as if *they've* completely come of age, either. If adulthood replicates so many childish dynamics, can we ever expect anyone to "fully come of age"?